|
Panel
Discussion: Adaptive Neurocontrol: Are we on the right path? Advances
in artificial neural networks in the past two decades have witnessed empirical
demonstrations of their capabilities, followed by rigorous mathematical explanations
of their validity. For example, in the 1980s, simulation studies revealed that
neural networks could approximate very nearly all functions encountered in practical
problems. In the following years it was conclusively shown by a number of authors
that neural networks are universal approximators in a precise mathematical sense.
Similarly, in 1990, it was suggested that neural networks could be used as identifiers
and controllers in dynamical systems. Following this, extensive simulation studies
were carried out, and empirical evidence began to accumulate demonstrating that
neural networks could outperform conventional linear controllers in many applications.
It once again became apparent that more formal methods grounded in mathematical
systems theory would be needed to quantitatively assess the capabilities as well
as the limitations of neurocontrol. When
neural networks are included as parts of nonlinear adaptive control systems, they
raise stability questions which are, in general, not mathematically tractable.
The difficulties encountered depend upon the class of plants considered, the prior
information assumed of the nonlinearities encountered, the domain in the state
space in which the trajectories are to lie, and the conditions under which
the neural networks are trained. During much of the 1990s, rigorous methods based
on linearization were developed, which are valid in a neighborhood of the equilibrium
state. In recent years,
numerous papers in prestigious journals have described solutions to very complex
neurocontrol problems. The assumptions made in these papers, the methods proposed,
the proofs presented, and the claims made of global asymptotic stability have
raised concerns among many members of the research community. The presentations
and panel discussion in the proposed special session will examine the above problems,
assumptions, claims, and the fundamental questions involved.
|